| |
Guiding Questions
|
What insights can we glean into Frank's life, the kind of
man he was, and his relationship with Nellie, from his Civil
War pension file? Did he always behave like a
mean-spirited son of a bitch? Or was his most violent
and abusive behavior limited to the immediate postwar years?
How did he treat his later wives? |
Evidence & Interpretations
This is a pretty long file,
and it
covers a lot of ground. Two sets of impulses were responsible
for generating the 25-plus pension-related documents transcribed
below. One was Frank's effort to get medical treatment, and
later, his disability pension -- and, after his death in 1904, his
widow Henriette Eichendorf Lang's effort to get his disability pension
transferred to her. A second impulse, working against the
first, was the Pension Bureau's resistance to Henriette's efforts by raising questions about Frank's marital history
and Henriette's legitimacy as his sole surviving widow.
(Photo of cooper at work; from
the
Collection of The Shelburne County Museum,
Shelburne, Nova Scotia, Canada)
In 1918,
toward the end of this lengthy
interaction, the paperwork took a nasty turn, as the federal
government, in the middle of fighting Germany in World War I and on
the cusp of launching the infamous anti-communist, anti-radical,
anti-immigrant "Palmer Raids" of 1919- 1920, alleged that 63 year-old
German-born Henriette was actually an "alien enemy" who held "fealty
to the Kaiser" and threatened to seize her farm. They also
harassed her son Rudolph, questioning his immigration status and
demanding to see his naturalization papers -- a sad coda to a pretty
depressing if revealing file.
(Photo of cooper at work;
from google.com/images/cooper barrel)
One thing the file shows
is that Frank's physically abusive
behavior largely stopped after Nellie divorced him in 1871 (though
his philandering did not). This evident cessation in his
violent outbursts tends to support the interpretation that the abuse
he inflicted on Nellie were rooted in the traumas he experienced as
a hospital attendant in the
Civil War.
The file also shows
Frank's need to
have a woman around -- or, more accurately, his determination to
have a wife. From his marriage to Nellie until his death he
never went more than nine months (Jan-Oct 1871) without one.
When second wife Minnie Tiner Lang was dying of tuberculosis in
1878-79, she went to convalesce at her parents' farm. Meantime he moved
to Wadena and became involved with Clara Morris. He married
Clara seven weeks
after Minnie died. Then, in the 13th year
of his marriage to Clara, he began seeing Henriette Eichendorf.
In May he divorced Clara and in June married Henriette.
As Clara's sister Bell Burke
recalled in
1918 , with
more than a touch of sarcastic humor,
"One thing I do remember. That was that when he first came
here to see Clara he was still wearing crepe on his hat, and we
had a good deal of laugh over it. I suppose he thought he
could not get along without having a woman about. What he
said was that he wanted a housekeeper. And I feel sure
that his wife had been dead more than a few weeks when he
married Clara."
The file lets us construct a fairly detailed
timeline of
Frank Lang's life from the Civil War to his death in 1904
(assuming Frank was born in March 1842, which we don't know for
sure, but it's close):
Age 19
(Aug 1861)
Enlists
in Union Army at Burr Oak, MI.
Age 19-22
(Aug 1861-Jan 1865)
Infantry private assigned as
nurse / attendant in Union field hospitals; "employed continuously"
(see his
service record)
Age
22 (12 Jan 1865)
Secretly marries Nellie Kinsman while on furlough from the army; assigned to Veteran
Reserve Corps the next day
Age
23 (7 Feb 1866)
Makes his marriage to
Nellie official
Age
24 (10 Nov 1866)
Birth of daughter Jennie Lang
Age
24 (Dec 1866)
Migrates with wife Nellie
and infant Jennie to Hastings MN (see
nellie divorce papers)
Age
29 (25 Jan 1871)
Divorce from Nellie finalized
Ages
29-37 (Oct 1871-Oct 1879) Married to Millie
Tiner (2 Oct 1871); living mostly in St Paul; Millie dies of
consumption on her parents' farm on 7 Oct 1879; Frank
leaves her several months before her death and
boards at the farm house of mother of future wife Clara Lang in
Wadena MN
Age
36 (1878)
Future wife Clara Morris bears
daughter Jennie Morris; not Frank's daughter
Ages
37-50 (Nov
1879-May 1892) Thirteen years --
apparently the most stable period of his life; married to Clara
Morris Lang (Nov 18, 1879), thereafter lives with her on farm in Wadena,
MN.
Age
41 (Sept 1883)
Son Frank W. Lang, Jr.
born in Wadena, MN
Age
47 (1889)
Frank, Clara, and Frank Jr. move to
Minneapolis
Age
49 (Jan 1892) Starts seeing Henriette
Eichendorf Lang
Age
50 (May 1892)
Divorces Clara Morris
Lang
Ages
50-62 (June
1892-March 1904) Married to
4th wife Henriette Eichendorf Lang
(June 17, 1892--March 19, 1904); living in South Haven, Wright Co, MN
Age
62 (19 March 1904)
Falls off a hay wagon,
hits his head, and dies
1905-1918 Widow Henriette Eichendorf
Lang tries to get Frank's pension money transferred to her.
No resolution by Nov 1918, when the file ends, though the 1920 census shows Henriette and Rudolph still on the farm. Did the
feds take their farm after that? We don't know; we need to
submit a request under FOIA and hope that the executive branch
chooses to obey the law. Nowadays, with the Bush-Cheney
power-grab, and the Justice Department's selective and discretionary
enforcement of the law, nothing in that realm is certain.
In fact, just as the administration
of George W. Bush has used the
pretext of the "war on terror" to break the law and
violate citizens' and others constitutional rights (warrantless
wiretaps, phone data mining, torture, illegal detentions of "enemy
combatants," etc. etc.), so too the administration of Woodrow Wilson
systematically violated civil liberties during in its war against
Germany and the "communist menace." Despite some obvious
differences, there are clear parallels between the present-day "war
on terror" and the era of the Great War and its aftermath: an
ill-defined enemy used to legitimate a vast extension of federal
power, stiffer laws that severely circumscribed basic civil rights,
systemic violations of constitutional guarantees -- in this case the Palmer
Raids, mass jailings, censorship, forced repatriations, the crushing
of the IWW in the lumber and mining camps across the West, and, in Wright
County, Minnesota, the threatened seizure of the farm of Henriette Eichendorf
Lang.
History does not repeat itself in exactly the
same way, but certain patterns do tend to recur, lending a degree of
regularity, even predictability, to an otherwise chaotic and
unpredictable process. In the wonderfully apt phrase of the
historical sociologist Michael Mann, history can be thought of as a kind of "patterned mess."
Many specific actions and events are random, contingent,
unpredictable; broader tendencies are often very predictable.
In the United States, the federal government's practice of using the
pretext of war to squelch
civil liberties and civil rights -- especially the rights of working
class and immigrant communities -- stands among the most
consequential and dangerous of those patterns.
From this broader perspective, Henriette
Eichendorf Lang should never have been accused of anything in the
first place, or victimized by all this paperwork -- which in the end is what much of
this file represents: a long and successful bureaucratic
delaying tactic that in a context of war suddenly turned
unnecessarily aggressive
and hostile.
Census data are
included here for convenience. Documents appear in
chronological sequence; some irrelevant sections of administrative
reports are not included.
The Documents
1860
U.S. Census, Lagrange County, Indiana
Frank Lang,
age 19,
b. Germany, farm laborer, Springfield Township, Lagrange
Co, IN.
[Note:
This farm was about 10 miles southeast of Burr Oak Village;
Frank erroneously listed as "Frank Laug" in the
Ancestry.com
database]
thumbnail:
_small.jpg) |
Frank Lang, Examining Surgeon's Certificate, Hillsdale, MI
1 Aug 1865
Examining Surgeon's Certificate. Hillsdale, Michigan,
August 1, 1865.
I hereby certify that I have carefully examined Frank Lang,
late a private in Co K, 16th Reg, V.R.C., in the service of the
United States, who was discharged at Harrisburg, Pa on the 14th
day of July 1865, and is an applicant for an invalid pension, by
reason of alleged disability resulting from Hernia.
In my opinion the said Frank Lang is one-half (1/2)
incapacitated for obtaining his subsistence from manual labor
from the cause above stated.
Judging from his present condition, and from the evidence
before me, it is my belief that the said disability was received
in the service aforesaid in the line of duty.
The disability is permanent.
A more particular description of the applicant's condition is
subjoined:
While at Deep Bottom, Va, about Aug 1864 was carrying the
Hospital Knapsack [----] stept into a ditch in the dark felt a
severe pain the right inguinal region, which soon developed into
a complete hernia.
/s/ Johh W. Falley, Examining Surgeon
thumbnail:
 |
Examining Surgeon's Certificate, Minneapolis MN
1 Nov 1868
Scrotal
hernia . . . one-third incapacitated . . . disability is
permanent . . . The hernia is large and comes far down giving
applicant much trouble about walking.
/s/ H H Kimball, MD
[Note:
this is the same medical doctor who examined Bailey T. Baldwin
during this same period and after; see
bailey t. baldwin
pension file]
|
US Census,
Hastings, Dakota County, MN
27 July 1870
Frank Lang,
head, 28, cooper, b. Prussia
Nellie
Lang, wife, 22, keeping
house, b. NY
Nellie
Lang, daughter, 2, b.
Minnesota
Jennie
Lang, daughter, 4, b.
Michigan
|
Marriage License, Frank Lang and
Minnie Tiner, Hastings, Dakota County, MN
2 Oct 1871
In Hastings, Minnesota, Justice of the Peace,
Frank Lang of the County of Dakota, Minnesota, and Minnie Tiner, of
the County of Dakota . . .
Witnesses /s/
Elza S. Abbett,
Nora C. Abbett
Signed /s/
C. W. Crosby
|
Death Certificate, Minnie (Tiner)
Lang, Hastings, Dakota County, MN
7 Oct 1879
Died October 7, 1879, age 27, b. NY, died of
consumption, father's John Tinar, b. Ireland, farmer, mother's name
M. Tinar, b. Ireland. Registered Oct. 21, 1879 [ copy
from original from Hastings, Dakota Co. ]
|
Marriage License, Frank Lang and Clara Morris, Red
Wing, Goodhue County, MN
18 Nov 1879
Frank Lang, County of Goodhue, and Clara
Morris, County of Goodhue, MN. Hans Johnson, Clerk.
Seal.
|
Marriage Certificate, Frank Lang and Clara Morris,
Red Wing, Goodhue County, MN
18 Nov 1879
At Red Wing, County of Goodhue, MN, Justice of
the Peace, Frank Lang of Goodhue County, Clara Morris of Goodhue
County, witnesses John Burke and John Bohmback Jr., Christie
Phillips, Justice of the Peace.
|
US Census, Frank & Clara & Jennie
Lang, Wadena, Wadena County, MN
1 June 1880
Wadena County, Town of Wadena, June 1880
Frank Lang, 38, head, farmer, b. Prussia,
father b. Prussia, mother b. Prussia
Clara Lang, 21, wife, keeping house, b. Penn,
father b. Penn, mother b. Penn
Jennie Lang, 1, daughter, at home, b. Minn
[Note:
This Jennie Lang is Clara's daughter from another man]
|
Application for Increase in Pension
25 June
1890
Claimant's
post office address: 619 Ontario St. S.E., Minneapolis
Right scrotal
hernia . . . receives pension of ten dollars per month . . . I
was ruptured in Va in 1863 while marching during the night.
I stepped into a deep ditch with one foot. I have not been
able to do my usual work for many years.
Pulse rate
70, respiration 17, temperature normal, height 5 feet 7 inches,
weight 150 pounds, age 48 years. A large right oblique
inguinal hernia is found, which is reducible and retainable.
The muscles, joints and tendons are sound as are all organs.
/s/ H H Kimball
|
Response to Pension Bureau Circular
4 July 1898
[ Q1: Are you married? If
so, please state your wife's full name and her maiden name.
]
[A1: ] Yes, Henrietta Lang, Henrietta Eichendorf
[ Q2: When, where, and by whom were you
married? ]
[ A2: ] June 17th, 1884,
Minneapolis, John Rodgers
[ Q3: What record of marriage exists?
]
[ A3: ] Certificate recorded in Clerk of
Court's office, Hennepin
[ Q4: Were you previously married? If
so, please state the name of your former wife and the date and place
of her death or divorce. ]
[A4: ] Yes. Nellie Lang "nee" Nellie
Kinsman
[ Q5: Have you any children living?
If so, please state their names and the dates of their birth. ]
[ A5: ] Frank Lang, September 1883, Rudolph
Lang, December 1st 1887
/s/ Franz Lang
[Note: both the latter dates are
way off, besides which Rudolph was not Frank's son and his
surname was not Lang.]
thumbnail:
|
US Census,
Frank & Henrietta Lang, Southside, Wright Co, MN
1 June 1900
Wright Co, Southside, June 1900
Frank Lang, head, 56, b. Nov 1843, farmer,
entered US 1860
Henrietta Lang, wife, 43, b. May 1857, wife,
entered US 1881
Frank Lang, son, 16, b. Oct. 1883, farm laborer
Rudolph Lang, son, 15, b. Dec. 1884, in school
Laura Lang, daughter, 12, b. Jan 1888, in
school
|
Deposition of John Alexander, Minneapolis, MN
3 April 1905
John Alexander, age 40, Hennepin County,
Minneapolis, address 621 Ontario St. S.E.
. . . That I was
intimately acquainted with Franz Lang from on or about 1890 until
his death and from Franz Lang I learned the following in regard to
his marriage relations. That Franz Lang had been married to
----------, by whom he had one child – this wife died in
Minneapolis, Minn, and then he was married to -----------, by whom
he had two children and this wife obtained from him a divorce – and
then he was married to Clara Lang by whom he had two children, and
then Clara Lang Lang obtained a divorce from him, and then he
married the claimant Henrietta Lang. At the time I became
acquainted with Franz Lang he was living with his wife Clara Lang.
I know
that after Clara Lang obtained a divorce from him that Franz
Lang was not again married until his marriage to the claimant
Henrietta Lang.
My acquaintance with Franz Lang was so intimate that I am satisfied
that if he had been married more than the four times as herein
stated, the fact would have in all reasonable probability been
brought to my knowledge
/s/
John Alexander
[See also John Alexander's second deposition 13 years
later, below. Frank Lang enlisted in Burr Oak, Michigan in
Company K of the Michigan 7th Regiment with a man named
John Alexander. It's entirely possible that this
is the same individual and he's lying about how long
he's known Frank; see
roster of company k of the michigan 7th]
|
Report of Pension Bureau Special Examiner,
Minneapolis, MN
7 Dec 1917
Board of Review, Case No 1089937
Henrietta, widow of Franz Lang, Co K, 7th
Mich Inf
The Chief, Special Examination Division
Reference for special
examination is made to determine the number of times the soldier had
been previously married; how and when such marriages were dissolved,
and whether the claimant has remarried since his death, March 19,
1904.
These parties were ceremonially married in the State of Minnesota on
June 17, 1892. The claimant represents that each had one prior
marriage, and in her pending claim she alleged that her former
husband died in 1889. The evidence in the case shows that the
soldier secured a divorce from his former wife, Clara, on May 5,
1892.
The testimony of John Alexander, filed April 11, 1905, indicates
that the soldier had three prior marriages but as his acquaintance
dated only from about 1890, he has no personal knowledge of the
prior marital history; in fact, he states that he based his
testimony upon what the soldier told him. The claimant it
appears has no personal knowledge of the soldier's early history and
was in ignorance of the prior marriages.
The soldier in his family circular of July 4, 1898, stated that his
marriage to the claimant occurred June 17, 1884, at Minneapolis,
Minn., and that he had been previously married to Nellie Krusman,
but he failed to state how or when her marriage to her was
dissolved. He named two children, Frank and Rudolph, as having
been born respectively, September 1883, and December 1, 1887.
If these children are living, they may be able to give information
as to the marital history of their father.
The soldier filed his original claim for pension in 1865, at which
time his address was Jonesville, Hillsdale Co., Mich., and it is
shown in the 80s that his address was Wadena and Minneapolis, Minn.,
and it is at these places that information as to the number of times
he had been previously married and how such marriages were dissolved
will have to be sought.
/s/
E. W. Young, Chief
Board of Review
[Note: This
is the same Special Examiner E. W. Young who in 1899
vigorously and fairly investigated allegations of
fraud filed by Aiken Bleau against local white
money-lenders in White Earth MN -- that is, 18 years
before this report; see
solving
the mystery of aiken bleau.]
|
Deposition of Henrietta Lang
10 April 1918
Southside Township, Wright County, Minnesota
My address is South
Haven, Wright Co., Minn, am keeping house here for myself and two
sons, Fred and Rudolph Lang. It is the same place where my
husband and I lived and where he died.
I was born in Alkinschau, Germany; I was aged about 27 years when I
came from there to the United States. I was born May 20, and
will be aged 63 next May. Do not know what year I was born . .
. . [her father and mother's name, previous marriage, five children
born in Germany brought to US, settled in Minneapolis, then husband
Eichendorf died a year after their arrival; etc ]
I continued living in Minneapolis until my marriage to Frank Lang,
my second husband, and for about four years afterward. And
then came to about a mile from this farm and have resided there and
here ever since. I was never separated or divorced from my
husband Lang. He sometimes spelled his name F-r-a-n-k an
sometimes F-r-a-n-z. he was called Frank by those who knew
him.
There was never any probate proceedings in his estate.
I got married to him in Minneapolis. . . .
SOLDIER'S HISTORY: I knew him from January till June, same
year, when we got married. A man named Budd made us
acquainted. Do not know his given name. He is dead.
He had been married before. He told me the name of his former
wife was Clara, her last name I do not know. I did not know
her. She was the mother of his son Frank. I know Frank.
He lived with us a couple of years after we got married. He is
now in Milwaukee. Do not know his address. He is a
traveling-man, do not know what he sells or for whom he travels.
He has had so many jobs.
Husband did not have a son named Rudolph. Rudolph took out
citizenship papers under the name Eichendorf, in Buffalo, Minn.
Husband Eichendorf was not a citizen of this country. So I was
not a citizen of this country until my marriage to Lang. . . .
Franz Lang, my late husband, came from Germany to the United States
when a little fellow, with his two older brothers, names I do not
know. I did not know them. I do not know where they came
first to the United States. He was a citizen of the United
States. . . .
Before he died, husband Lang told me his brothers were in Colorado.
Did not send them notice of his death. He did not know himself
where they lived there. He had no sister in this country and
only these two brothers. Do not know what became of Clara or
if married.
I know of his living at Wadena, Minn., before he married me. I
do not know how long he resided there. Do not know the name of
anyone who knew him there. I do not know of any other place he
was except in Michigan, where he joined the army. Do not know
where he lived in that state. . . .
I never heard of any wife he had except Clara, until I heard it
after his death. Yes, he was coming to see me before he was
divorced from Clara. He came to Budd's place, by arrangement
with Budd; and I went over there to see him. This is in
January. Yes, he was coming to see me from then on or may be a
little later. . . .
I do not know who or where any other wife of his ever was. I
think Clara was the mother of Frank Lang, son of my late husband.
I do not know of any other child he ever had. I bore none to
him.
No, I never heard of his wife Nellie. I never heard of Nellie
Krusman. Do not know who she is. Hear you read what you
say is written in a statement which I see bears his signature:
that his former wife was Nellie Krusman. I never heard of her
before. And that his son Frank was born in September 1883, and
that he had, in 1898, a son named Rudolph born Dec. 1, 1887. I
do not know who this Rudolph is, unless he refers to my son Rudolph,
who was all the time making his home with us, and who has always
been with me. Rudolph was aged 34 years last December.
His Frank and my Rudolph were nearly the same age. . . .
. . . . I have no attorney . . . etc.
/s/ Henrietta Lang
|
Deposition of Rudolph Eichendorf
10 April 1918
Southside Township, Wright County, Minn.
My age is 33 years
last Dec. 2, my postal address is South Haven, Minn., a farmer.
This claimant,
Henrietta Lang, is my mother. I was born in Germany, and
Julius Eichendorf was my father. I was aged only between 3 and
4 years at his death, and do not remember him.
I was naturalized at
Buffalo, Minn, June 5, 1911.
I knew Frank Lang, my
step-father. He lived in Wadena and Minneapolis, Minn., the
only places I know of, until he came here. I do not know how
long he lived in Wadena. I do not know of any one who knew him
there. He was farming there, before I knew him.
The only child I know
of his having was Frank Lang. Do not know where Frank
is. Last I knew of him, some 4 or 5 years ago, he was in
Minneapolis. He was then a traveling salesman; do not know for
whom he was working. Gus Jaekels, was last fall cashier for
the Gund Brewing Company in Minneapolis, and he and Frank used to
come up here together, in auto.
I never knew or heard
of my step-father Frank or Franz Lang having a child named Rudolph,
and none other than Frank.
I know twice of my
said step-father being married before his marriage to my mother:
One wife was Clara, mother of Frank; the other was Minnie, and I do
not know what the name of either of them was before marriage to him.
Clara died. Do not know where; but he was written to, I do not
know by whom, to send some money for her gravestone. I do not
know that he sent the money.
I do not know what
became of the wife Minnie. I do not know where he and Minnie
got married or where they lived. Do not know whether she died
or whether they were divorced or anything about it.
I never heard of any
other wife he had. I never heard of Nellie Krusman.
I do not know of any
one who was acquainted with him before he came into my mother's
life, except John Alexander, Minneapolis.
I hear you read the
statement which I see bears the genuine signature of Franz Lang; in
which statement it is made to appear that he was married in 1884;
that he had a wife named Nellie Krusman; and that he had a son
Rudolph, born in Dec 1, 1887. I do not know anything as to any
of those facts.
I have no interest in
this pension claim, except that it is my mothers, I stay at home
with her, am not married, and look after her, the farm belonging to
my mother. There was no estate settled after his death.
This farm has always been in her name since we have had it.
Mother has not married or had any husband since Frank Lang's death.
Q: How did you
hear of Minnie?
A: I do not
know. Think I heard of her, but do not know whether I ever
heard him speak of her. . . .
/s/
Rudolph Eichendorf
|
Deposition of John Alexander, Minneapolis
12 April 1918
My age is 53 years, my
address is 816 6th Ave. So., Minneapolis, Minn., I am a
grocer.
I became acquainted
with the older Frank Lang when I resided at 621 Ontario St., and he
was living at 619, next door to me. This was some 3 to 5 years
before he left the city and went to the farm where he later died.
I knew his son Frank. When I became acquainted with him, he
was living with his wife Clara, mother of the son Frank. I
knew Clara. As I understand it, she died in this city, living
with a man to whom not married. I do not know who the man was.
It seems to me that it would be close to ten years after the divorce
between her and Lang that she died. But that is only a guess.
He had been previously
married, as he told me. I know only what he told me of it.
Did not know the woman or her name, or where he married her, but
they had a child and her parents here took the child, as he told me.
I do not know who the parents of her were. Do not know whether
the child was a boy or a girl. That was his first wife, as I
understand. They were divorced. Do not know where it was
obtained or by whom. But from the way he spoke of it, I think
it was in this city. Do not know where he married her, but
rather think here.
Then he had a wife between her and Clara, name I do not know.
I understand from what he told me she was from Minneapolis, and I
know of her only what he told me. I never knew her. He
said she had two grown-up children, I believe both girls, but do not
know their names. I never knew them and do not know what
became of them. It was here in the city he lived with her.
As he informed me, he and that No. 2 were divorced. Do not
know who got the divorce. As he told me, she just went off and
left him, and would not live with him. The third one was Clara
and after her he married this claimant, Henrietta, whom I know. . .
.
Those above named are the only wives I have any knowledge or
information of Frank Lang's ever having. I do not know whether
any of them is Nellie or Minnie. . . .
Frank Lang was a cooper when residing next door to me.
He also had a daughter, of whom Clara was the mother. She is
married, was living in this city the last I knew, some ten years
ago. I do not know whom she married. She was older than
her brother Frank. . . .
I have it: Lang's daughter by Clara was Jennie. OK.
/s/
John Alexander
|
Declaration of Rudolph Eichendorf, South Haven, MN
16 April 1918
Dept of the Interior, Bureau of Pensions, St.
Paul, MN
April 12, 1918
To Mr. Rudolph Eichendorf, South Haven, MN
Sir: If your
half-brother Frank Lang had a full sister, please give me her full
name and address as last known to you, stating when that was, and
the name of her husband if she is married. Early reply is
requested. Did you find the naturalization papers? /s/
Special Examiner E. W. Young
[ handwritten response: ] My memory goes back
15 years and there are some facts that I [was] in error. To
the best of my knowledge the above Frank Lang had no full sister,
but he had a half-sister named Jennie by a previous marriage.
I have not heard of her for about 15 years and at times she lived in
Minneapolis but her address was and is unknown to me. She was
married to a man named Walter Thornhill whose address I never knew.
Yours truly, /s/ R Lang
[ typescript: ] St. Paul, Minn, April 16,
1918
Respectfully returned. Can you tell me
where and about when Jennie married Walter Thornhill? Was her
name Jennie Lang until her marriage to him? (over)
[reverse side not photocopied – bummer!]
|
Special Examiner E. W. Young, St.
Paul, to Commissioner Pensions, Washington D.C.
29 April 1918
W.O. 1089.937
Henrietta Lang of Franz Lang, K, 7 Mich. Inf.
Address: South Haven, Minn.
Dept of Interior, Bureau of Pensions, St. Paul,
MN
April 29, 1918
[To] The Commissioner Pensions: . . . .
Issues: Dissolution of all former
marriages of the soldier [Frank Lang], except to that of Clara; any
remarriage of the claimant. . . .
This claimant
[Henrietta Lang] is evidently an alien enemy. Asked for her
husband, the soldier's, naturalization papers she exhibited an
advertisement as to how to become naturalized. Her son Rudolph
thought he could find a certificate of naturalization and mailed to
me the soldier's declaration of intention which was executed in
Minneapolis, Minn., Oct. 31, 1867. This I returned to him.
He has offered no other. Rudolph himself, claimant's son by
her former husband Eichedorf, has been naturalized. This
claimant never has been. She is the owner of alien property.
Finding from the divorce records in case of soldier vs. Clara that
marriage in Red Wing, Minn., in 1879 was alleged, I secured a
certified transcript of the marriage record. This is the
beginning of the authentic record of this soldier's marital career.
But from Red Wing am unable to trace any one: witnesses to a
marriage ceremony, the bride's family, or any one else.
Clara evidently was his wife during the whole period of his
residence at Wadena, where there is no record of any other marriage
or of divorce.
Nor is there record of any other in Minneapolis, than those we
already have in the brief.
In short, I have exhausted every resource here.
He seems to have had a daughter or step-daughter named Jennie who
married Walther Thornhill. I fail to find in Minneapolis a
record of Jennie. In the Minneapolis directories I find the
name of Walter, listed also as Walter G. Thornhill. The
directory does not show Jennie Lang. But running down the
directories from 1890, I find Thornhill boarding until the 1901 book
shows his residence 1010 Nicollet Ave., the same place where Jennie
Thornhill is shown as a dressmaker. After the 1907 issue the
entire family disappears and there is no trace to be found of them.
. . .
It looks as if we shall have to go to Milwaukee, Wis., where I find
Clara's son by the soldier, namely, Frank Lang, was stopping at the
Republic Hotel, the last address I can find for him, which was when
he quit the Pure Oil Co. of Minneapolis, sometime last fall.
Frank should be asked whether he has ever been naturalized; as to
what became of his mother; who the woman was to whom the soldier was
married before marriage to Clara; and what has become of his sister
(see John Alexander's testimony herewith).
Further examination is recommended accordingly.
I kept in view Order March 20, 1917.
Very Respectfully,
/s/ E. W Young, Special
Examiner
|
M. Dawkins, Chief of Special
Examinations Division, Bureau of Pension,
Washington, to Ernest W. Young, Special Examiner,
St. Paul, MN
11 May 1918
. . . The above named
claim was referred for special examination to determine, among other
things, the number of times the soldier had been previously married
and how and when such marriages were dissolved.
From an examination of all the paper it appears that the soldier was
married at least once, and perhaps twice, prior to his marriage
November 18, 1879, to Clara Morris, from whom he was divorced May 5,
1892, the names Nellie Krusman (or Kuesman or Kinsman) and Minnie
being mention ed as former wives.
It appears that the soldier lived in Wisconsin [circled to bubble
reading "Minn"] from about 1868, in early days making his home in
Minneapolis and Wadena, just when he went to Wadena not being shown.
Before moving to Wisconsin [circled to bubble reading "Minn"] his
home appears to have been in Hillsdale, Mich.
[Recommendation to interview Charles A. Nimocks of Minneapolis.]
Correspondence filed
in your report indicates that there are persons at Wadena who knew
the soldier from a date prior to the time when any of the witnesses
who testified before you knew him, but it does not appear that you
made endeavor by personal interview to develop the information
desired.
The case is returned to you for the testimony of Charles A. Nimocks,
and any other available evidence bearing on the point in question.
It is also suggested that while the case is in your hands you
endeavor to verify the present address of Frank Lang, for whose
testimony you have recommended further examination.
Very respectfully,
/s/ M. Dawkins, Chief of Division
|
Deposition of Charles A. Nimocks, Minneapolis
29 May 1918
My age is past 75
years, my residence and address are The Leamington Hotel,
Minneapolis, Minn. . . .
I did not know Frank Lang before enlistment. He and I at the
same time enlisted in the 7 Mich. Inf., both as privates, I in Co. C
and he in some other, and do not know which one. I was later
made Hosp. Steward, and later became lieutenant and he was in the
hospital as a nurse, and I saw much of him and became well
acquainted with him from then on. He was a German and spoke
with a German accent.
Some years ago, ten or more, he called on me concerning his pension,
and I recognized him as the same Frank Lang who had served with me
in the 7th Mich. Inf. I never knew any wife he had.
But I believe that when he called on me here he spoke of his wife,
either that she had then but recently died or that he had married,
or something of that kind. I do not know whether he was a
married man in Michigan.
He and I both enlisted at Jonesville. Immediately after the
war I resided at Hillsdale, Mich. For 7 years and then came here.
Hillsdale is 5 miles from Jonesville.
I do not know who was any wife he had or the name of any. Or
who any child was. Know nothing about his family. . . .
/s/ Charles A. Nimocks
|
E. W. Young, Special Examiner, St.
Paul MN, to Commissioner Pensions, Washington D.C.
31 May 1918
I am returning
herewith all papers . . .
A careful review of
all the papers fails to show that the soldier was ever at Wadena
prior to his marriage to Clara, and probably not prior to 1883.
His address there first appears in his declaration filed in December
of that year. And he probably left there in 1889, when he
traded his Wadena farm for a Minneapolis house. . . . At the time I
reported the case formerly, it was evident that Clara Morris was his
wife all the time he was at Wadena . . .
The soldier filed his
first declaration from Hillsdale, Mich., where he had his first
medical examination Aug. 1, 1865. My former report shows that
he took out naturalization papers in Minneapolis, Minn., in 1867.
There is nothing in the papers to show that he was outside Minnesota
thereafter. . . .
. . . it seems that
our only source of reliable or direct information is the soldier's
son Frank Lang. . . . He is in all probability an alien enemy . . .
As I understand, he is a man without family and might not be found
if he I ascertains the government is seeking him. And he is an
important witness.
I am free to confess
the utter denseness of the matter of finding the papers wherein it
is stated that the soldier ever resided in Wisconsin, as stated in
Bureau letter returning the case to me. I think the volume and
page will have to be designated to this benighted intellect. [
see letter of May 11, 1918 ]
My recommendation is
as before – Milwaukee, Wis., for the testimony of Frank Lang.
/s/
E. W. Young
|
Commissioner Pensions, Washington, to
E. W. Young, Special Examiner, St. Paul, MN
12 June 1918
Soldier was pensioned
on June 11, 1869, to date from July 14, 1865; his first certificate
was sent to one A. Plummer, Minneapolis, Minn. His original
declaration was filed August 21, 1865, and he then gave his
residence as Jonesville, Hillsdale County, Michigan. He was
identified by Gilbert Chaddock and Byron Ellis, of same address.
In that declaration soldier stated that he enlisted at Burr Oak, St.
Joseph County, Michigan. In a declaration filed on November 7,
1868, the soldier gave his address as Minneapolis and stated that he
lived in Michigan a short time after his discharge and from that
time on in Minneapolis; he was identified by Jacob Murbach and
Charles Rampag. On December 17, 1883, he filed an application
for increase giving his address as Wadena, Wadena County, Minnesota;
he was identified by J. Katzky and Louis Metzger.
The medical certificates show that the soldier was examined as
follows: at Hillsdale, Mich., August 1, 1865; Minneapolis,
Minn., November 1, 1868; St. Paul, Minn., September 4, 1873,
September 4, 1875, and September 4, 1877; at Wadena, Minn., on April
30, 1884, and August 22, 1888; and at Minneapolis, Minn., on June
25, 1890. [ rest of letter missing from file ]
|
I. D. Laferty,
Special Examiner, Milwaukee WI, to Commissioner Pensions,
Washington D.C.
11 July 1918
. . . I found Frank W.
Lang, to procure whose deposition the claim came to me to be a
reputable fellow. He is not an alien enemy, having been born
in this country, though his father seems never to have been
naturalized. He freely told me all he knew of his father.
He does not know much which will aid in the settlement of this claim
but supplies data for further inquiry. . . .
I suggest further examination as follows, namely:
At Minneapolis, Hennepin Co. Minn. For the testimony of Mrs. George
Morris (Clara's mother) No. 2817 Morgan Avenue North, as to
soldier's marital history prior to his marriage to Clara.
There are also three (3) of Clara's sisters residing in Minneapolis
and they might possess knowledge of value. . . . There is another
sister, a widow, Mrs. Mary Meier, residing at 266 Lafayette St.,
Winona, Winona Co., Minn; a brother George Morris, Jr. – express
messenger – residing in Seattle, Washington . . . and Clara's
daughter, Mrs. Walter C. Thornhill – sister Jennie – resides at
Wenatchee, Chelan Co. Washington. It is now disclosed that
Clara was a widow when Lang married her and that Jennie is not
Lang's child.
Should old Mrs. Morris and the daughters to be found in Minneapolis
not be able to clear up the soldier's marital record prior to his
marriage to Clara, then the other data referred to in the preceding
paragraph should be utilized.
/s/
I D Laferty
|
Deposition of Frank W. Lang, Milwaukee, WI
11 July 1918
. . . I am 35 years of
age; a traveling salesman, selling automobile accessories. My
postal address is 549 40th Street, Milwaukee, Wis.
I am the son of Frank and Clara Lang. I was born at Wadena,
Minn. August 10, 1883 so I have always been taught.
I last saw father alive perhaps 8 months before he died.
He died while living on a farm near South Haven. I attended
his funeral however. I know this claimant, Henriette, and
father and this woman were living together at the time he died which
was in 1904. He died during the month of March but the exact
date I do not remember. He fell off a load of hay, lit on his
head and was killed. I do not remember the exact date in
March.
I remember father's marriage to this woman. I was somewhere
around ten years of age at the time he married her. She was a
widow, named Eichendorf who had five children when he married her.
My mother's name was Clara whose maiden name was Morris. I
believe – have always heard – that she and father were married at
Red Wing, Minn. Mother had two children by my father, sister
Jennie who now lives in Wenatche, Washington. Her name is now
Walter C. Thornhill who runs an automobile shop out there. She
is not, however, my full sister, that is to say she was a daughter
by my mother but by a different man, mother having been a widow when
Lang married her. So that I am the only child of Frank Lang by
Clara.
Mother is dead now, died in Minneapolis in 1891. She was dead
two years before I knew it and I do not, therefore know the exact
date of her death. Her name when she died was I believe Grenier,
first name George – not Frank nor Paul as I remember but George.
My sister, being five years older than I, will know more of this
than I do. Mother procured a divorce from father.
I am pretty sure she procured it in Minneapolis but the date I do
not know for it was before I was old enough to know much about such
things.
I am not sure as to the date of death of my mother. I might be
wrong about that. If they were not divorced until 1892 I must
be wrong but I do not think she lived as late as 1903. As I
remember she died when I was about 18 years of age. Oh yes she
died after father married this claimant.
I do not know that father was married before he married my mother.
I never heard that he was. I have no half brothers or half
sisters on my father's side so far as I know or ever heard. As
I have the story father and mother married in Red Wing; lived there
awhile; then moved to Minneapolis; then father bought a farm at
Wadena and lived there awhile and then moved back to Minneapolis
where they separated. I do not know how long they lived in Red
Wing or in Minneapolis the first time or in Wadena or in Minneapolis
the last time before they separated. Mother had no children
but sister and me. My grandmother – mother's mother – is yet
living. Mrs. George Morris, 2817 Morgan Ave No, Minneapolis.
She is living with her niece, Mrs. Laymon Locke. There is one
brother living, namely George Morris, Jr., Seattle, Wash. I do
not know his city address. He is an express messenger on the
Northern Pacific. There are also sisters as follows, Mary,
May, and Belle and Ida. Mary is now a widow and resides at 266
La Fayette Street, Winona. Her name is Mary Meier. She
is my mother's youngest sister. I do not know the names or
addresses of the other sisters but Mary or the grandmother does.
I think they are all in Minneapolis.
I do not know where father resided prior to his turning up in Red
Wing. The home of mother's parents was at Red Wing where I
suppose he met her but how long he had been there or where he had
lived prior to meeting her I do not know. I did not know that
he ever resided in Michigan. Neither do I know what service he
rendered.
As hitherto stated, I never heard that he was married before he
married my mother. I never suspected that he was previously
married. I do not know the name of mother before she married
father but the name of her former husband I do not know.
Grandmother will know all about that. I do not know how that
marriage was dissolved.
I never heard of a woman named Nellie Krusman, or similar name, in
connection with father. Neither did I ever hear that he had a
wife named Minnie. If Rudolph states father had a wife named
Minnie perhaps he did but I never heard it before today.
I never heard that father had brothers or sisters and I know of no
one aside from possibly mother's mother and sisters who will know
anything of father's marital relations before he married my mother.
I well remember a John Alexander who lived next door to us and he
and father were intimate. He was and is a reliable man and if
he says father told him he had been married twice before he married
my mother I have not the least doubt but what he did but I never
heard of it. As stated, I never heard of a Nellie Krusman or a
Minnie. Neither did I ever hear that he had children by any
woman save by my mother.
I have no interest in this matter . . .
/s/
Frank W. Lang, 11 July 1918
|
Deposition of Ida Rose, Minneapolis, MN
4 Sept 1918
My age is 48 years, my residence and address are 506 15th Ave N.,
Minneapolis, Minn., am the wife of Peter Rose, a lineman.
Clara Lang was my full sister. Frank Lang was her first
husband, whom I knew well. He got a divorce from her.
Then she married George Grindel, here in city. They were
separated for a time, but were living together the last year of her
life. She died in this city, in the 300 block, 2nd house from
University on 2nd Ave, S.E. I do not know when she died, but
about 25 or 30 years ago – all of that. She was buried under
the name Grindel in the family lot at Lakewood Cemetery. I
really do not know how long she has been dead. I was not in
close touch with her. She was kind of hard to get along with.
I do not know Frank Lang, her husband's, first wife. I heard
of her; heard that he had five children by his first wife. Do
not know where he lived with her, or where or who any of the
children are. I do not know and never did know, when, where,
or how sister Clara became acquainted with him. I was aged but
ten years at the time and did not pay any attention to it.
Clara was working about Cannon Falls, which was our home at that
time and where mother, Mary Jane Morris, still resides.
Q.
And not Sarah Jane?
A. Well, May be
it is. Father just called her mother, about the house.
She resides at Cannon Falls. Father, George T. Morris, is
dead.
I have a brother,
George F. Morris, residing in Seattle, baggage-master, do not know
on what road. . . . He is next to the oldest of us children, Clara
being the oldest. Then Belle, Sadie, now dead; myself, May,
Mary, and Charlie, dead.
I do not know how you
can get any trace of Frank Lang's first wife, unless sister Belle or
mother can tell you. Mother's memory is bad, as she had a
stroke of paralysis. But sometimes she is fairly clear.
I have no financial
interest in this claim.
Father was a soldier,
and mother is a pensioner . . .
/s/
Ida Rose
|
Deposition of Cora May Morey, Minneapolis,
MN
4 Sept 1918
My age is 45 years, my residence and address are 1205 Bryant Ave.,
No., Minneapolis, Minn, am the wife of Arthur G.
Morey, whose business is a druggist.
Clara was a full sister of mine. Her first husband was Frank
Lang. Her last was George Grindel. She is dead.
Died here in this city. She was divorced from Frank Lang.
I was at her funeral. She died when I was aged 32 years when
she died. She was buried at Lakewood Cemetery.
I knew Frank Lang, her husband, who fell off a wagon and broke his
neck on the farm. They were married, she and Frank, in Red
Wing, and then came back to mother's home, our home, in Cannon Falls
and lived with mother there until they went to their farm at Wadena,
Minn. There they lived together all the time they were at
Wadena. We became acquainted with Frank when he came to Cannon
Falls to work as a cooper. That is where Clara got acquainted
with him. Do not know where he had been or where he came from.
None of us knew him till he came to Cannon Falls.
It was not till after his marriage to Clara that we heard that he
had ever been married before. Other men who came there to work
in the cooper-shop who knew him and his first wife, and boarded in
my mother's home, for she kept a boarding-house, told us that he had
been married before. I do not know who any of them was or
where any of them came from or where they knew Frank Lang and his
first wife. I never knew or heard that he had any child by his
first wife, and do not know what the name of his first wife, who she
was, where she was from, or where any of her people were.
He never told us that he had been married before he married Clara,
and we knew nothing about it till the other men came there who knew
him and her; and they said that first wife was dead. But I do
not know who they were.
I have no financial interest in this claim.
I guess Frank Lang coopered about a year in Cannon Falls after he
married Clara before going to Wadena.
The foregoing is
correct as read to me.
/s/
Cora
May Morey
|
Deposition of Sarah J. Morris,
Cannon Falls, Goodhue Co, MN
23 Sept 1918
My age is past 76 years, my residence and address are Cannon Falls,
Minn., am a widow, keeping house for my daughter Belle. I am
pensioned as the widow of George T. Morris, E & B, 3 Pa H.A., under
certificate No. 840,418.
I had a daughter named Clara, whose first marriage was to Frank
Lang, who, I believe, was a soldier. I did not know him very
well. Before her marriage to Frank Lang, she gave birth to a
child called Jennie, and whom Frank Lang took to bring up and did
bring her up. I do not know who her father was. Clara
was not at home at that time. She never told me who was the
father of Jennie, who was born in my home.
I first met Frank Lang when he came here to this house to see Clara,
who was at that time working out, do not know at what place, but it
was in the country here about Cannon Falls. This was after
their marriage. No, I never knew Frank Lang until after their
marriage. No, he never boarded at my place. I kept
boarders, but he was not one of them. He was here at the house
once when I was not at home; and I never saw him until after their
marriage. He was a cooper when she married him, and they moved
right away when they got married; do not know where to, but I think
to Minneapolis. I do not know whether they ever lived at
Wadena, or where they lived.
Clara has been dead 20 years or more. She died in Minneapolis.
I was at her funeral. She was the wife of a man named George Grindel,
who also, I understand, has since died in Minneapolis.
These are the only husbands I ever knew of Clara having. I do
not know whether there was a divorce between her and Lang.
Yes, I believe Frank Lang was married before his marriage to my
daughter Clara. He and that former wife lived here in town, in
a row of houses, perhaps a quarter-mile from my home. I do not
know where he married that former wife, or what her given or maiden
name, or who any of her folks were, and did not know her. But
she died before his marriage to Clara. I was not at her
funeral. I do not know where she was buried. But I saw
the funeral procession going past my house here, which is the main
road right to the main part of Cannon Falls. I live across the
river from the main part of the town. So did they. They
lived near the mill.
Q. How is it you know so little of your son-in-law, tho he
lived in the same small town as you?
A. I never knew him before he married Clara and they left here
right after.
Q. How did he board and live at your place after their
marriage, if they left immediately after?
A. They came her for just a short time and then moved
away.
I hear you read the testimony of daughters May and Ida, as to Frank
Lang's first wife. It does not help me. I do not know
that he had five children by his first wife; do not know that he had
any child by her. I believe it was his wife's funeral that I
saw. I supposed it was.
I do not know where he married his first wife. I have no idea
who knew Frank Lang here. I do not know this claimant or who
she is. Have no interest financially in this pension matter. .
. .
/s/
Sarah J. Morris
|
Deposition of Anabelle Burke, Cannon Falls, Goodhue Co, MN
23 Sept 1918
My age is past 58
years, my residence and address are Cannon Falls, Minn., am the wife
of J. E. Burke, who does not live with me. I am at home with
my mother, Sarah J. Morris.
I had a sister named Clara, who was the oldest of us children.
I am next to her. My earliest recollection is of this
town of Cannon Falls.
Clara's first husband was Frank Lang. But she had a daughter
named Jennie before her marriage to Lang. I do not know who
was Jennie's father. But Frank Lang brought her up.
Clara died in Minneapolis about 19 or 20 years ago, under the name,
- well, I do not know. Do not know whether it was Grindell.
I was in Iowa and in various places.
Frank Lang was married once and only once, so far as I know or ever
heard, before his marriage to my sister Clara. I did not know
her; I really almost knew nothing of Frank Lang. But we knew
at the time of his marriage to Clara that he was a widower.
His first wife and he lived her in town, where he was a cooper.
She was sick with the consumption and she was taken to her folks out
in the country here about Cannon Falls. Do not know who her
folks were or where it was that they lived. She died out there.
I knew that at the time he married sister Clara and it was so
understood. It was clearly the understanding hereabouts and in
our family, that he had no wife living at the time of his marriage
to Clara. His first wife died in this, Goodhue, county.
If he had any child by his first wife, I do not know it. I do
not know where sister got any such idea. I was living at home,
had never been away from home, at the time that Lang married Clara.
I was not married until after Lang and Clara got married.
One thing I do remember: That was that when he first came here
to see Clara he was still wearing crepe on his hat, and we had a
good deal of laugh over it. I suppose he thought he could not
get along without having a woman about. What he said was that
he wanted a housekeeper. And I feel sure that his wife had
been dead more than a few weeks when he married Clara.
I have no idea who or where any of his first wife's folks were.
I do not know who this claimant is and have no financial interest in
this claim.
If, as John Alexander states, he had one or more wives in
Minneapolis, it is new to me. I did know of his wife here;
and while I had no personal acquaintance with her, I knew where
they lived and would see her as I would go past their home. And
that woman, I know as well as any one can know without being present
and seeing her, is dead and was dead when he married sister Clara.
The foregoing is correct as read to me
/s/
Bell Burke
|
Commissioner, Pension Bureau, to Hon.
A. Mitchell Palmer, Alien Property Custodian, 16th &
P Streets NW, Washington D.C.
21 Nov 1918
Dear Mr. Palmer,
I have the honor to state that Special Examiner Ernest W. Young of
this bureau in his report of September 28, 1918, with reference to
the pension claim of Henriette Lang, of South Haven, Wright county,
Minn., as the widow of Frank Lang, late of Co. K, 7thh Michigan
Infantry, original No. 1089,937, states, among other things, that
the claimant owns a first-class farm and other property, and that
she holds fealty today to the Kaiser, and is registered with the
postmaster, at St. Paul, Minn., as an alien enemy.
In her deposition of April 10, 1918, Mrs. Lang testified, among
other things, that she was born in Alkischau, Germany, the daughter
of Johnann and Louse Schwonke; that she was married to her first
husband, Julius Eichendorf, at Palaschke, Germany, and that she was
married to Franz Lang, at Minneapolis, Minn., on June 17, 1892.
Very truly yours, Commissioner
GCS/jem. [ stamped "Law Division" at top ]
[ NOTE: Mitchell A. Palmer headed
the predecessor to the FBI in the Attorney General's office of the
Department of Justice, and staged a series of "raids" against
suspected "communist, anarchists, and foreign agents" in 1919-1920
that have become infamous as examples of civil rights violations in
US history. Also, this letter is dated ten days after the
formal end of WWI, on November 11, 1918 (Armistice Day). So
all these allegations of "fealty to the Kaiser" and "alien enemy"
are completely fabricated, not to mention beside the point since the
Kaiser and Germany are defeated. The rest of the file is
probably in Justice Dept records in the National Archives, perhaps
available via FOIA. The Post Office is also mentioned; perhaps
they have a record of it. Chances are excellent that her
"first-class farm" was seized as "alien property." ]
|
|
|